베르까우어(G. C. Berkouwer)와 회퍼(D. Bonhoeffer)의 사상 비교

 오래됐지만, 재미있고 중요한 논문(PDF)입니다. 20세기의 유명한 개신교 신학자들의 신학을 존재론(ontology)과 인류학(anthropology)으로 간단히 비교합니다.

 본디, 개혁교회에서 조직신학은 반드시 신앙생활과 선교에 직결됩니다. 이점을 고려한 아주 좋은 내용입니다. 둘의 장단점을 '죄(sin)'라는 테마를 중심으로 다루는데, 평신도들에게 직접적으로 많은 도움이 됩니다. 

 * (논문작성시) 비슷한 방식으로 다른 개신교 신학자(본 회퍼 대신)를 비교연구를 하시길 추천합니다. 불행인지 다행인지 지금 한국개신교에 소개하면, 아주 좋을 것 같습니다.^^

BONHOEFFER AND BERKOUWER ON THE WORLD, HUMANS, AND STN, Bouma-Prediger_Steven_198406_MPhilF_Thesis.pdf

2.33MB

---

 * 이 논문은 목차만 업로드합니다.^^

INTRODUCTION.................................................. 1

Chapter 1 DIETRICH BONHOEFFER .............................. 8
 I. The General Structure of Bonhoeffer's Model ......... 9
  A. The Horizontal Dialectic ......................... 9
   1. Ethics ......................................... 9
   2. Letters and Papers from Prison ..............19
   3. Earlier Works .................................. 22
   4. Other Writers.................................. 25
  B. The Vertical Dialectic ........................... 29
   1. Ethics ......................................... 29
   2. Creation and Fall .............................. 33
  C. Summary ......................................... 37
 II. Sin Within Bonhoeffer's Model ......................... 39
  A. As Denial of Responsibility....................... 39
  B. As the Unnatural or Organization ................ 49
  C. Summary .............................................. 52

Endnotes....................................................... 54

Chapter 2 G.C. BERKOUWER .................................. 60
 I. The General Structure of Berkouwer's Model ......... 61
   A. Key Biblical Themes................................ 61
   1. Creator/Creature Distinction ................ 61
   2. Normativity.....................................64
 B. Monarchianism.....................................68
   1. General Revelation ......................... 68
   2. Providence .................................. 89
   3. Man: The Image of God .....................95
   4. Other Writers ................................ 111
 C. Summary.................................115
 II. Sin Within Berkouwer's Model ....................... 117
  A. As Misdirected Relationship to God ........... 117
   1. Sin ............................................117
   2. Other Works.................................. 121
  B. Summary........................................... 127

Endnotes..................................................... 129

Chapter 3 COMPARISON AND EVALUATION.....................137
 I. General Similarities ................................ 140
 II. Evaluation of Bonhoeffer's Model .................. 149
  A. Strengths ......................................... 149
  B. Weaknesses ....................................... 152
 III. Evaluation of Berkouwer's Model .....................158
  A. Strengths......................................... 158
  B. Weaknesses ....................................... 162

Endnotes.....................................................168

CONCLUSION.................................................. 171

BIBLIOGRAPHY................................................ 174